Extraordinarily good news from Communications Daily (behind a pay wall, unfortunately):
The Motion Picture Association of America is unlikely to push for a broadcast flag component in DTV legislation establishing a 2008 hard date because the bill's main author, House Commerce Committee Chairman Joe Barton (R-TX), is against the provision. Meanwhile, the MPAA will keep briefing House and Senate members on a broadcast flag bill's importance and seek other ways to get the content protections it wants.
A new Congressional Research Service report raises concerns that the broadcast flag's technological limitations could hinder activities normally deemed "fair use" under copyright law. For instance, students might not be able to email themselves copies of projects incorporating digital video content because no secure system exists for email transmission. "The goal of the flag was not to impede a consumer's ability to copy or use content lawfully in the home, nor was the policy intended to 'foreclose use of the Internet to send digital broadcast content where it can be adequately protected from indiscriminate redistribution,'" the report said, quoting from the FCC order.
We're seeking a copy of that report, and will post when we find it; stay tuned.
Update: It looks like the "new" report [PDF] was released in April, before the DC Circuit struck down the Broadcast Flag. It repeats the FCC's assertion of authority to impose the Flag but also notes the objections of public interest organizations (Public Knowledge, EFF, et al.). Evidently, the new bit is that Congressman Barton is (presumably) citing the report to justify his distaste for Broadcast Flag provision, a use we couldn't possibly encourage more.
Update #2: Courtesy of the hard-working policy analysts at the Center for Democracy and Technology, here's a version of the CRS report [PDF] that was updated post-Broadcast Flag ruling. You may also want to check out the coverage @ Wired and a scathing critique of the Flag from the Chicago Sun-Times:
- Broadcast Flag at Half Mast? [Wired]
- TV Industry Gets Flagged Over Another Evil Plan [Chicago Sun-Times]
